Thursday, May 2, 2013

Addressing Educational Disparities in Urban Settings

          


Dietrich Bonheoffer, the great German theologian pointed out in the middle of the 20th century that the test of the morality of a society is how it treats its children.  A statement of American abolitionist Frederick Douglas from more than century and a half ago sheds light on the critical importance of properly educating today’s urban young.  Douglas intimated that “literacy unfits a child for slavery.”  Similarly, today education unfits children for poverty, addiction and incarceration. 

It is important to give constructive attention to the education of children in urban areas because – as Marian Wright Edelman of the Children’s Defense Fund points out - urban children  face the higher likelihood of being abused and neglected, born into poverty, born without health insurance, killed by a firearm, or born to a teenage mother.  These figures are exacerbated for black and brown children in urban settings.[i] 

The 2005 “Equality Index,” published by the National Urban League sheds light on the challenges of urban education today.  It points to significant disparities among urban and suburban educational systems in several areas, including the quality of education (including teacher quality and credentialing), as well as educational attainment/achievement.[ii]

According to statistics compiled by the national “No Child Left Behind” initiative, the percentage of teachers who are “highly qualified” in their specialty areas is typically higher in the wealthiest school jurisdictions.  For instance, in the Baltimore-Washington Standard Metropolitan Statistical Area (SMSA) in three of the wealthiest/best performing school districts: Fairfax County, VA, Montgomery Co., MD and Howard Co., MD over 90% of teachers are reported to be highly qualified.  By comparison, in three of the poorest/worst performing school districts: the District of Columbia, Prince George’s Co., MD and Baltimore City, less than 55 percent of teachers are reported to be highly qualified.[iii]

Several studies point out that differences in academic achievement among Black, Hispanic and White children appear early in the elementary-school years and persist throughout the elementary and secondary-school years.  Dr. Freeman Hrabowski - president of the University of Maryland, Baltimore County - and his collaborators in the book, Beating the Odds: Raising Academically Successful African American Males - point out that a report on the performance of elementary school children in Montgomery County, Maryland shows that the percentage of Hispanic and Black children that fell behind their White peers in mathematics increased markedly between the first and sixth grades.  At the second grade, more than 15% of Black and Hispanic children and approximately 5% of the White children were performing below grade level.  By the sixth grade, the performance of 20 % of White children, while the performance of over 40% of the Hispanic and 50% of the Black children, was below grade level.[iv]

Many Black and Hispanic children live in urban settings where school systems typically receive far less funding per student than their suburban counterparts.  The difference in funding, for example, for students in the city of Baltimore and Montgomery County, one of the wealthiest counties in the country, is almost $2,000 per student per year.[v]

The development of constructive, collaborative approaches to addressing the issues surrounding educational disparities between urban and other settings present some of the most critical opportunities for turning the tide on the blight now evident in many of our communities.  

Entrepreneurial educational initiatives such as Teach for America (www.teachforamerica.org), The Algebra Project (www.algebra.org), The Northwood Appold Community Academy, Baltimore (www.nacacad.org),  and  Room to Read (www.roomtoread.org)  offer four diverse approaches to addressing educational disparities, and warrant further investigation in developing a comprehensive model to enhance educational achievement among underserved populations in urban settings.

Notes 


[i]  Robert Franklin, Crisis in the Village: Restoring Hope in African American Communities (Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2007), 20.
[ii] National Urban League, The State of Black America-2006: The Opportunity Compact (New York: National Urban League, 2006),  p. 133 f.
[iii] See The Washington Post, January 13, 2007.
[iv] Freeman Hrabowski, IIII, et. al., Beating the Odds: Raising Academically Successful African American Males (Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, 1998).
[v] The Washington Post, January 13, 2007.

No comments: